School uniforms were compulsory in my school, as is the case with most schools, public and private, in India. The only place I don’t see uniforms in action are the low rung government schools where the wards of the people on the lower end of the economic scale have to be lured in by (positive) gimmicks such as the mid day meal. It makes sense too, it is already a giant leap forward for these kids to be attending school, no need to make it even harder for them by making uniforms compulsory.
So where exactly does the debate begin? Frankly, I didn’t even think this was a topic worth discussing since I already am long out of school and I don’t have any children to send to school, but a bit of browsing on the internet made me think, could something like this have an effect on the students? Let’s discuss.
PROS
Having school uniforms gives a sense of camaraderie in the students. It makes the students appreciate their classmates as being equal to them. Hence, it reduces chances of bullying over choice of clothes/accessories and doesn’t let a social class divide to arise.
A corollary to the above point would be that it demolishes already existing class/economic barriers. I shared a class with sons of millionaires (black money) and with the son of the school peon. Had there been no uniforms the difference would have been glaring but nowhere during my days of schooling, I found any visual difference between the two.
It increases a sense of belonging in the students and adds to the school pride. A lot of times, competing schools even get into feuds as to which one is better. The styling of the uniform is always a comparison point.
It encourages discipline. Most of the times, the uniform not only prescribes a particular shirt and pant/skirt but also rules out outlandish hairbands or chains or unnecessary accessories used to up the cool quotient or risque styles of wearing said dresses.
The most important point in favour of school uniforms is the easiness in identifying intruders on campus. Today’s world is not safe. Period. While it is true that the kids can anyway be kidnapped off the street while going to or returning from the school, having the school safe is a welcome comforting thought to a parent.
CONS
The biggest con here is the violation of freedom of expression. With just the school uniform to rely on, the creativity, uniqueness and individuality are seriously compromised on. Also consider the fact that students in India are merely followers, very few become leaders. Having a freedom of choice in clothes from an early age could at least let the kids explore their own identity, experiment a bit, try a few new things and whatnot. Only by taking smalls decisions on their individual will would prepare them for taking bigger decisions as they grow up.
Another con here would be the financial trouble the parents would face having to constantly get new clothes for their fast growing kids. It may not be a concern for the likes of you and me dear reader but it is for the not so well earning poor people who would skip a meal to save for their ward’s tuition fee.
What are your thoughts on school uniforms? Do let me know in the comments section below.
Much love,
–SG
Yes. I believe school uniforms should be compulsory. They disguise the difference between the haves and have nots and prepare children for the workforce and team work.
LikeLiked by 7 people
That’s a fresh viewpoint. Thanks. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a great point…
LikeLiked by 2 people
I like my son has to wear a uniform. It keeps all kids alike and fair.
LikeLiked by 5 people
That’s how I liked it too. 🙂 The good ol’ days.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Some of my siblings went to Catholic school for awhile. They had uniforms
LikeLiked by 3 people
Ooops, hit send haha.. but they had dress down days certain times of the year so they would be able to wear their normal clothes to school. It was usually a fundraiser. So each student could bring $2 to dress down for the day. It was required but they had the option.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Sounds like a favourable compromise.
LikeLiked by 1 person
They had a few options for boys and girls to wear too. So it wasn’t 1 shirt and 1 pant/skirt every day. It seemed to work out pretty well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
In our school we used to have two colours for pant/skirt. If it was a Physical Training (P.T.) day we had to wear white pants with white cloth made shoes. Damn I miss those comfortable shoes. On other days we had brown pants with black shoes.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s how it here too…
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m always fascinated by the west indies. Tell me more about the life you have there. Perhaps a series of posts. I’m sure your international readers like me would love it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh that is already brewing…😊
LikeLiked by 2 people
Stay tuned…😉
LikeLiked by 2 people
The comment about removing socioeconomic boundaries assumes uniform does a complete job. As a parent I can assure you, this isn’t true. Children can still recognise those barriers in themselves and each other whether it be via schoolbooks, lunches, hairstyles or shoes.
My issue with formal education is the filter applied to children’s thinking. Don’t give them uniforms so that they won’t pick on each other, teach them not to bully. It might look like discipline if you fail to follow the code but the reward for conformity is a numbed brain. Why install a sense of belonging to a government institution? Give them the skills to think critically and decide for themselves where they want to belong.
A school uniform doesn’t replace a child’s wardrobe. The two exist together and that combined expense is worse than allowing children freedom to wear what they want.
My preference is for uniforms, I just wanted to add a few more points on your topic. 🙂
LikeLiked by 5 people
First of all, the combined expense you speak of cannot be afforded by everyone here. I kept in mind the economic condition of my compatriots while writing this piece, but if one can afford both, your point is valid.
A sense of belonging isn’t to the government “institution” but the collective ecosystem that it curtails within. A comparable example is when a soldier is at duty in a warfield, he’s not only pledging himself to his country/side but he’s pledging to his comrades right beside him fighting alongside him. What my point here is, a feeling of communal brotherhood is good for you, even if it is for a so called “institution”.
Of course we should tell our kids not to bully, but at the same time we should also level out the differences that give rise to such behaviour. A bully picks on others that he deems to be different and is insecure himself about it.
All in all, just having or not having uniforms is obviously not going to solve any problems, The socioeconomic barriers can be seen, but they become a bit less obvious,
LikeLiked by 2 people
I don’t understand, you clothe the child for seven days a week until they start school, then have to buy a complete uniform…to supplement the adequate supply they already have…this is an added expense. I recognise the economic differences in our countries but it’s an added expense for parents in either. Please don’t dismiss my point because you think I can afford it.
I also want to recognise the difference in individualism and collectivist culture of our respective countries. The differences can be seen in our responses but recognising the differing ideologies might help us to understand each other.
The children learn side-by-side, play together, express and communicate to each other. This is what provides their sense of community…being active in the community and exchanging experiences with others. Again, the uniform might promote the idea but take the uniform away and the idea can still develop.
We agree then that uniforms alone don’t stop bullying. Should we issue approved footwear, books, pens, haircuts to the children? Using the uniform to displace differences when we are all unique, in my opinion, misses the mark.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Sadly the lower rungs can’t even clothe their children for 7 days a week. I don’t have a gripe with you being able to afford it, all I’m trying to point out is that for some people, even essentials such as food and clothing are luxuries. Hence, my point here being that if these people are given free education (which they are), why add a hidden cost in uniforms. In fact, I have seen a lot of poor students that buy uniforms and don’t have enough left to buy regular clothes, so they wear the uniform clothes outside school too.
As I’ve mentioned earlier, both in my response to you and in the post itself, uniforms do have their drawbacks and it is wrong to try and implement such strict codes but then again, nothing is perfect.
LikeLiked by 3 people
You’ve raised some very vital points and I agree, especially where you speak to critical thinking, the institutional aspect of education systematically diminishes creativity and independent thought, I can speak because i am a product of that system.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Having to wear uniforms has nothing to do with and in no way interferes in the independent thinking or creativity of a child. Our education system does that anyway!! A common dress code gives children a sense of comfortable familiarity and uniformity. I am for uniforms!!! 😊
LikeLiked by 3 people
Haha, that’s an interesting quip, although if our education system were a bit more fair, I do think the correlation between uniforms and individuality would have affected some children at least.
LikeLike
Nice idea 😊😊
LikeLiked by 4 people
I love the idea of school uniforms. Having passed out of school only a few months ago, I still have the teensy shirt I had worn in the first year of my schooling and the largish shirt all signed upon by my friends and teachers I had worn on my last day. Being one of the less rich students in class, I can relate to the point that though people would notice I couldn’t afford to have my legs waxed every week like them, I wasn’t bullied for my choice of clothing. But above all of that, the familiar shirt and skirt brings good memories of the time we were in school- making a new bff every five minutes and fighting every ten as a six year old to falling in and out of ‘love’ with a different person every week as a seventeen year old, that uniform has seen it all, and I see it in that.
LikeLiked by 5 people
My God! I didn’t know that you’re a girl. 😮
Also, where are you from?
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m from India. And I don’t usually behave the stereotyped way girls sometimes behave, though I’m not fully tomboyish. Even my friends tell me that I carry myself like a boy and I’m not like the other girls.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Aha! I knew it as soon as I read the phrase “passed out”. Only us Indians use that phrase in that context. 😀
Anyway it is nice to know a bit more about you my lord.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Passed out was a force of habit, though I remember some others like ‘mugging’ a textbook for the exam and the like. And I really liked this piece. It’s brilliant.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Also who could forget the “take a right from the” dead end””quip. 😀
Although that one is more prominent in the south. In North we just use hindi for directions.
LikeLike
I’ve heard that about taking the right from the ‘dead end’ , having spent most of my life in the South. Not to mention the direct translations from Hindi or another vernacular language into English. I’ve heard a guy ask ‘What I did?’ Apparently having translated from ‘Maine kya kia’ directly. India is one country to live in. I guess the diversity we find here is unique.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes most people here fumble at the grammar and placing of words. Sometimes, by the pattern of the way someone speaks English, you could even predict their mother tongue. 😀
It’s the subtle differences.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is. I’ve already tried my hand at that in college, where I find people from all over the country.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s an interesting social hobby to have. I too try it when meeting new people.
LikeLike
But I can’t say it is accurate enough. Some people speak such good English, it becomes difficult to pinpoint a place they might be from.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You still have a lot to learn my lord. 😉
LikeLike
I do. I admit. 😅😅😥
LikeLiked by 1 person
Same here !!! 🙂 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I never had to wear a school uniform. I don’t think I would have felt like I belonged or fit in anymore than I did, if I did have to wear one. Sometimes it’s just personality differences that make people feel like black sheep. I don’t think it would have bothered me to wear a uniform, but I don’t think it would have made a difference.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Most of the times, it doesn’t either, but it is fascinating to explore how it could or could not make a difference for others.
LikeLike
I agree, I always thought it was kind of cool to see people with uniforms, but then again I also loved wearing what I wanted lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
I went to school with no uniforms, I live in the US and not all public schools are uniformed based. My step-daughters school does require uniform, both get frustrated with the limited school wear and not being able to wear what they like. Though it is easier for us parents on spending less for clothes, plus this school year they have changed the dress code to include new allowances for kids to dress a bit more comfortable than before, instead of certain pants and only collard shirts, jeans are now allowed and solid color shirts with the specific school colors. I think as a student it can seem annoying, but you do mention some good cons that com from uniform wearing. Only thing I will disagree on, is bullying (for around here) is still a really big issue despite kids being dressed the same.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Agreed. That’s a whole different debate. One could think of many ways to prevent bullying but uniforms won’t make it to the top of that list. But then again, something is better than nothing.
LikeLike
*pros not cons
LikeLike
Inspirememom makes the point I was about to make.. here in the States it was popular for uniforms being in non-public schools.. or parochial schools, typically Catholic. I think in those cases uniforms were more an issue of economics given the demographics tended to be the poor who could not afford a wide variety daily wardrobe for their kids; nobody is embarrassed if they look the same as everyone else.. There’s the other broader reason that uniforms make people “uniform”.. hence removing a measure of individuality and the tendency for the young to be preoccupied and distracted from their studies with the natural competitiveness of how they appear to their peers. The religious schools might go so far as to claim that wearing a uniform illustrates that in God’s eyes all people are the same. Uniforms also serve as a bit of advertising; the colors and patterns being identified with the school and it’s image of prestige and elitism in order to get more business. For school administrations uniforms reduce the periodic social need to address the desires for changing dress codes, and enforcing them.
Quite honestly, there’s nothing but pro’s for school administrations requiring uniforms. The con’s are likely more about child development and social self-esteem issues, given the obvious perception is that uniforms take away individuality.
In the military when you enter basic training the first thing they do is shave your head… illustrating the fact that there is no class structure nor expressions of individuality and everyone is the same. Uniforms in the military establish identity on the battlefield.. so you don’t kill your fellow soldiers by mistake, but it also supports the illustration of the military being a team and not a collection of individuality.
LikeLiked by 5 people
I completely agree with the military equivalence sir. I somehow overlooked the point of school prestige and elitism in the post, so thank you for pointing it out too.
Have you served in the military?
LikeLike
Yes I have.. Air Force back in 1971-1975.. the Nixon years.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I think school uniforms are good because they encourage the kids to forget about name brands but that doesn’t exclude $150 sneakers unfortunately.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I think uniforms should cover shoes too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have noticed some very expensive shoes in schools. I agree.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A unique post!!
I’m of the opinion that school uniforms must be compulsory. They foster the feeling of unity and equality among the students.
Moreover wouldn’t it be a difficult task to get up everyday and choose an outfit to wear for the day. I used to feel cool about the college when I was in school, cz you don’t need to wear those boring uniforms then.
But now when I’m grown to be working and getting up everyday with lots of things on the head including this one, ” what to wear today”..😁
Honestly I wish we had some dress code in the office too😁
LikeLiked by 5 people
😂i feel the same way…
LikeLiked by 2 people
Haha.. I think lot of people do😂
LikeLiked by 3 people
Haha didn’t think of it that way.
LikeLiked by 2 people
So you found my point of view unique, didn’t you??😂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Of course I did Nidhi. 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
some of them are comfortable but some of them are veeeryyyy bad it’s awful 😟😂⭕️
LikeLiked by 4 people
It should be compulsory cos it portrait decent nature to the society
LikeLiked by 2 people
Congratulations SG; An good essay and so many interesting and differing views on the subject. I’ll pass on this one. Having turned 80 I think I can say without fear of being arrested that I would like to see all girls over the age of 18 dressed in school uniform.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hahaha, naughty you. 😀 😂😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
The article is really good! I don’t know if my point is sensible but many a time
I feel we had this habit in office too so we dont say: have got nothing to wear at early morning. Uniform gives me a feeling of staying united all the time.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I suppose that it has a bigger impact than I thought, both psychologically and socially.
LikeLike
Yeah you’re right.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think uniform is good mainly on secondary school when kids start to be more aware of what they wear.Kids are all the same and fair.I don’t really think it is a limitation to expressing personalities.personality must be expressed through attitude not clothes beside they can wear what they like in their free time .
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes. Although the school is largely the place where peers interact the most but still a very valid point.
LikeLiked by 1 person
May be also depends on where you live I don’t know.for example my girls school has no uniform but it’s very very small(only 70 kids) is a primary and kids don’t care about what they wear or labels etc.Parents are quite sensible too I have to say but I know that,for example,in Italy is very different.Since primary kids are exposed by their own parents to fashion dictates but not everybody can afford the same things and this can create problem and exclusions.
P.s
Laundry wise then uniform are definitely easier on mothers😉happy Sunday my dear❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha, sometimes it could be a laundry wise nightmare too, especially in rainy days when one’s PT day uniform wouldn’t dry well enough to be worn (alongwith the cotton shoes).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah,there is no escape from laundry then🤦🏼♀️I’ll be dealing with uniform in 2 years with my eldest one ,ill let u know….it will be then double the trouble🤓
LikeLiked by 1 person
Personally, as much as I enjoy fashion and creativity. I would have to say it would be a lot easier if uniforms where inforced in more schools. Since, it may take a lot of the peer pressure and bullying out of play. More so, kids wouldn’t focus so much on what they are wearing. Honestly, my younger self would have been opposed to this way of thinking. However, as I’ve matured and experienced my entire educational experiences. I have a different perspective and now believe the utilization of unforms in the learning environment are very beneficial. Sometimes it can be a big distraction in school. Plus, like you mentioned it could help many families that can not afford to buy their children trendy clothing. It’s sad but many bullies and wealthier children feel superior to less unfortunate children. Mainly, because they have all of the cool trendy clothing and accessories others may not have the leisure of owning. However, it is not the children’s fault their parents are unable to afford certain things others may have. In the world we live in, so many people try to keep up with the Joneses. Most of us are always wanting more as well as wanting what others have. Although, what people do not realize is it is not the most important thing to have. Being educated, caring, compassionate, loving and giving are true qualities. Not having all the material unnecessary things of the world. Of course, being human we do all want things that are nice. Although, if we sit back and think about it, it is certainly not the most important. So with all that being said, I believe more in uniforms than individual clothing in the school setting. Most of all, I believe it alievates many burdens both parents and youth face.
I apologize for the lengthy comment. I just was very moved by this article.
LikeLiked by 3 people
My God, you could even have written an entire post as a reply to my article. 😂
The thoughts you have put forth are highly profound and thought provoking. I seriously recommend fleshing this out a bit more and posting it as a post of your own!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh wow, thank you, I may do that. Sometimes I get a little too in-depth with my thoughts when responding in the comment section. I just really enjoyed this read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
School uniforms shouldn’t be expensive, especially when it’s compulsory.
School uniforms can increase safety of children by using right colors (right because it’s depending from area of school and time of a year) and adding glares, which is really useful when school is around the street, to make drivers to see them (children) easy and quickly.
Glares do very good job after dusk and in some areas on the World are months when sun is setting early.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Considering that you’re from Poland which is much nearer to the Northern hemisphere, I completely see your point.
As far as being expensive is concerned, the sad truth is a lot of people can’t afford even basic cotton threads, I guess schools should provide uniforms to the financially less fortunate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is why I mention it’s can’t be expensive. When it’s compulsory it’s mean for all, when it’s for all, then it have to be possible for everyone to have it. No one can be forced to buy school uniform instead of food.
But it’s so easy to say…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey cousin. I love uniforms and I think they should be compulsory. I think there would be less competition to look better, parents would save money on clothing and you would also be good for the environment since there would be less textile pollution.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Great points. Also, are you really my cousin? If yes then let’s go bowling!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Completely agree with the thoughts. School uniforms should be compulsory, sonehow I feel a sense of belonging comes with them to the institution. Though its the same colour n pattern for all, but still uniform stands u apart from the crowd.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yeah. Do they have uniforms in your daughter’s school?
LikeLike
Yeah.😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am for school uniforms. It maintains uniformity and sense of belonging which is really important. As for expression; I believe that there are days that kids don’t go to school and they could “express” themselves then
LikeLiked by 2 people
Very true.
LikeLike
I agree having uniforms gives student the feeling of being equal. For my school each program has a different uniform we have to follow but really gives a sense of one program being a team and being united . Although I’m not sure on a financial cost my school helps students with cost of uniforms so all student are given the same opportunities.
LikeLiked by 3 people
If the school indeed helps with the cost of the uniforms, then I must say it is a very welcome step.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It reminded me of the school time debate competitions. Well presented by you. 😁
LikeLiked by 2 people
I agree with everything you have said here, I am a high school kid my self and I believe school uniforms make you look like a certain person and they don’t let us have a certain hair colour or piercing and this isn’t letting us be who we want to be but I do understand some work places don’t allow this either x
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree with some of the views above. School is the place where uniformity is taught. Take a day when children are allowed to put colour dress. We can note the variations in the expressions and the reactions of children. May be kids or students doing higher education it will be evident. Only because of this uniform we ourselves in our school days were the best friend of a actor’s son or daughter or a famous doctors son or daughter or a chay wala son or daughter.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m for uniform. I think that students can be really equal.
In Italy, where I live, students don’t wear uniform.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes. I do not have enough clothes that are not pyjamas for the winters and not boxers for the summer.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It should be compulsory to learn ki hm sb ek hai. Koi garib or koi ammee nhi
LikeLike
So you’re in favor?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Uniforms must be different in the mainland because I currently live in Hawaii and we just have a t-shirt as a uniform. But my biggest trouble is the argument that it teaches students about modesty, but they don’t even have a choice in what they wear. I feel like if students got the freedom to make choices we can see what kind of choices they make and find the best way to guide those who need it. Btw student ID can solve the security problem.
High school is a time where students are transitioning to
become adults and they are still trying to find an identity. Instead of being so controlling we need to make them feel less like they’re in prison and be able to have that respect of being treated like young adults who know how to dress themselves. Dress codes are enough to guide in the right direction.
If we want students to make right decisions we first need to allow them to make decisions.
Students will always be in competition with one another, if not who has the best clothes, it’s whoever fills it out better. The best body competition and students have other ways of showing off how rich they are by jewelry or their devices.
LikeLike
Uniforms for me are the first line of identity of being the school’s student. Even from distance you can be recognized. It takes a lot to approach and ask about it.
LikeLike
Well Presented by You!!
In my perspective, I think Uniform is must because it brings a feel of equality for all.
LikeLike