“Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.”
The above quote is apt in context of the topic at hand. The world is largely a poor place. The developed countries where there are fewer poor people have low population while the continents like Asia and Africa, which contribute to a significant majority of the population are majorly filled with people that barely have enough to get by. Add to that the fact that the richest 1% of the world own 40% of the world’s wealth, more than the poorest 95%. In such a case, it becomes ever so important to bring as much equality as possible and alleviate poverty.
The most logical course of action here is government action. Theoretically, no one else should care about the well being of the people more than the government itself. A healthy, wealthy and sound population only improves a country’s standing at the world stage. However, rampant corruption and incompetence among government officials means most of the efforts go in vain, if there are any. As the title suggests, the government policies do not target the root causes of poverty, leading to recent non poors to fall back into the trap, or even make some people destitute for the first time in their lives.
A recent example of this would be MGNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act) in India. It was devised to guarantee 100 days of paid work (unskilled manual labour) to labourers in a calendar year. Now, the concept is simple and well meaning. Not only does this guarantee work to people who may not find it otherwise (like older people who won’t get farming jobs) but it also would help develop rural infrastructure like roads, canals and other public property, hence increasing the overall profile of the rural areas.
Now, the problem with this system lies in the fact that the wages are still low, and are mostly siphoned off by middlemen. Also, 100 days out of a possible 365 days isn’t really enough to feed a family, let alone bring it out of poverty. Another point to note is that the said work is on paper only and in reality the workers just sit around and do nothing. (Okay maybe they smoke a bidi or two perhaps.) As such, they’re virtually being paid to do nothing, which doesn’t encourage them to work hard and earn better and they start expecting freebies.
Hence it is safe to say that while noble in intention, MGNREGA doesn’t do enough to target the root cause of poverty and offers only a temporary solution whilst being plagued by corruption and mismanagement of money which hampers even the bit of good it set out to do.
This just brings us back to the quote at the top of the article, the current government policies are only obsessed with getting people the fish, while only a minority of the people actually know how to fish. So what exactly does the phrase “teaching to fish” means in this context? In my opinion, it would be to focus on skill development and employment generation. No need to “guarantee” employment to anyone, just create enough jobs for everyone and then there will be no need for any such “guarantee”.
Now, it is much easier said than done, but we have got to take some initiatives in this direction. The recent “Make In India” campaign focuses on making the country a hub for manufacturing and in the process bringing in a lot of employment opportunities, coupled with that is the “National Skill Development Mission” which focuses on making the youth ready for the influx of skilled labour requirements.
These initiatives are supposed to create more jobs and improve the skill level of people so that they have an easier time finding employment. A major challenge faced here is getting the poor people signed up for such skill development measures. For all we know, such people are chronically poor and cannot afford the fee for such programs, hence keeping them in the circle of poverty. In this case, contrary to what I said previously, a freebie is to be expected from the government in terms of a scholarship, just enough to nudge the people in the right direction, which is being provided currently, so to speak, as the government has allocated Rs 17,000 crore this year to the Skill India Mission, an amount which is supposed to go to government and private institutes that specialize in skill development.
Yet still, the true effects of any of this remains to be seen. I don’t expect poverty to just eradicate within the next 15-20 years, but I sure hope to see some improvements.
I would love to hear what your opinion is regarding what is the root cause of poverty, and what sort of policy could deal with them? I really feel I could have fleshed this out a bit more, so a help from your side would really be appreciated. As usual, the comments section is wide open. Also, follow me on Twitter.
Much love,
–SG
Firstly, I appreciate your way of analysis on this issue. I agree with your points which demonstrates the root cause of poverty in India.
Second, poverty is a vicious circle. In 1950s when our population was significantly low as compared to present day, still overwhelming poverty was ubiquitous. Hence we can assume evidently that poverty, besides other factors, is behind overpopulation which again reciprocate poverty.
I, therefore, opine in order to diminish poverty substantially we need to curb rampant growing population disproportionately.
LikeLiked by 8 people
An extremely refreshing viewpoint there Rishi. I had completely overlooked that aspect, thank you for pointing it out. The data you put forth really shows empirically how more number of people are competing for equal (maybe even less) amount of resources as compared to the non poor countries.
As far as condom ads are concerned, while I agree some of them were very risque and controversial and should have been rightfully banned, I really do not agree with the decision to ban all such ads between 6 AM and 10 PM. I mean, how else are people supposed to know. If you have such a big problem with the content, improve the class of the ads, not just ban them.
A solution to this should be more condom vending machines in key places, because, you know, a lot of people are embarrassed to buy condoms at the hands of a shopkeeper. 😀
LikeLiked by 2 people
Exactly. I don’t understand why to feel ashamed while purchasing contraceptives which prevent unwanted pregnancy and check STDs. It’s completely ironical and sort of paradoxical situation.
Keep posting because I love to read your blogs☺.
#Merry Christmas..
LikeLiked by 1 person
The feeling is mutual friend. Jai Bholenath!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jai Bhole! 😁
LikeLike
Let’s take few examples across the world; China has fertility rate of 1.57, the U.S- 1.57 and India stands at 2.40. The World Population Prospects: The 2017 Revision report released on June 21, 2017 recorded two other dramatic facts: The fertility rate of Indians has more than halved over the last 40 years to 2.4
Recently, The government has prohibited television channels from airing advertisements for condoms any time in the day till 10 pm. No sex education in schools. Isn’t it hypocrisy?
LikeLiked by 4 people
The initiatives sound promising. It will be interesting to see the future direction. I was impressed by the work ethic of the Indian population I met while working in the UAE. I noticed that they had very good computer skills also. They left for better opportunities and better pay as many from the United States, Europe, Philippines, and other countries. That was a challenging year for many 2008-2009.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Well there are people of all sorts here in India. We have the hardworking people that you see, we have lazy drunks, drug junkies and just plain hopelessly poor people too. You’d be surprised to know just how many and how many kinds we are.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oh no I wouldn’t. We have the same variety here in the United States and in most countries I have traveled to. Only the more ambitious leave their country for better pay and more opportunities.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Ambitious like you. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
The more ambitious, the more desperate or simply the very curious with a goal in mind. Because you never know what awaits you on the other side!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The last time I left the county for the UAE in 2009, the economy was tanking everywhere. I met teachers who left their home country after having lost everything including houses and often either the husband or wife accompanying them were without a job. There were teachers in similar positions from the UK, Australia, South Africa, the Philippines, etc.. The situation with the beginning ADEC reform was not easy and many didn’t last the year.Some fared better than others. It was the luck of the draw and of perseverance of the fittest, mentally and physically in the beginning. Possibly it has improved. My husband stayed with our home and his job in the states while I went alone which was challenging but I completed the contract. As the economy improved, people returned but I still have friends seduced by the lifestyle in the UAE who have never left since 2010. Others simply went on to other countries. Many have returned as the economy improved.
LikeLiked by 2 people
That’s an interesting perspective.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Interesting times. I also have a big interest in the Middle East and one of my linguistics graduate school’s project involved a study about the people and the culture of the Middle East. My husband knew I needed to go and it was a fascinating experience but I know I couldn’t live there for 8 years. One to Two would be the tops but I am glad I went.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Sounds nice. Although I must say the number of temporary subcontinental workers far outnumber the native Arabs in most countries there. Especially in UAE over 75% of the population is desi and only 17% are native Emiratis. Must have required a lot of social analytics to take that into consideration in your studies.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My MA is in linguistics so my studies were completed prior to leaving for the Middle East. I have always had a big interest in this region. You are right: most of the workers you meet are from other countries and the wages are very good. Hence people continue to come. If you have a chance to visit or go, I would say you would enjoy it. I believe the UAE is the most embracing of other cultures, faiths, and nationalities than other Middle Eastern countries.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for writing and sharing! Unfortunately, it is hard to predict when or even if poverty will be eradicated. World-wide we rather see a growing gap between rich and poor. And that is not what I personally want to see. On another note, where have you been? I did not see a post from you in a while. I hope everything is ok. Warm greetings!
LikeLiked by 3 people
Thanks. I’ve been fine.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really like the article. As always with a SG trademark style of putting every aspect.
I liked the point where you mentioned to enhance skill and create job opportunities and not guarantee.
The gap between rich and poor is dangerously increasing. Also leading to theft , burglary. It is a very serious issue.
Indian government on poverty.. seems to liking it. As they are east vote bank target.
Lots of love and hugs
Jay:)
LikeLiked by 4 people
Thank you Jay. That’s the problem, the government feeds off of the insecurities of people and uses them to their political advantage.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Poverty is a universal mindset; its roots go pretty deep. Yes, I do believe it started with a government that only granted opportunities to a certain caliber of people. I believe this left the culture of the impoverished in a place to depend only on the government for assistance; because they were left with no choice. However, things have evolved and no one is left out of the pool of opportunities. Everyone seems to have a chance now to be anywhere they desire to be; but not everyone easily ceases the opportunity. Which goes back to the point of poverty being a mindset. It takes some longer than others to grasp that better and greater is universal!
LikeLiked by 5 people
Add to that the fact that poor people have low morale and always feel defeated even before anything has begun. From a certain point of view, it is true that poverty is a mindset.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I’m doing a project for school where I research deeply about six places around the globe, focusing on one aspect. Could you explain more about the ‘Make in India’ campaign? It sounds really interesting.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Of course. Check these out:
Also, if you have any further queries do contact me through the contact page.
LikeLike
Thanks so much! And I will.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think you point out the main causes, and we have known about them for a long time. People might pay lip service to wanting to change the status quo, but there is no real political will to affect the change.
LikeLiked by 2 people
True. True.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree with you.When the solution you suggested is concerned, isn’t the poor are too desperate to go for long term solution?
Poor people are not looking at the solution to get rid of their poverty but to survive the day to day life.Thats going to add up fuel for the burning fire.
I think freebies along with good education will do!
I wish I could come up with something better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lol
LikeLike
Sure
LikeLike
This is a complicated issue. While the government has a big influence on the movement of economy and societal well being, I believe there is also a limit to what it can and can’t do. You make a great point about corruption and intention. In an ideal world, an ideal government could fix the root cause of poverty. But, of course we live in the real world, where so many government initiatives and programs go wrong. Generally speaking, I think the best thing governments can do is provide an infrastructure that supports job growth. Education is a big factor in equipping a society with the tools to work in a variety of industries, but more importantly the family structure is the most vital aspect of any society. Will, motivation, healthy mental stability are all supported by the family unit. The best thing a government can do is support policies that support the family unit, and provide access to education, whether that be secondary education or education in different trades.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Am sure agreeing with you.. Govt. Are sure influenced by the people. It’s just as limited as the people.. Well we all should go with the capitalist system of govt…. Where people don’t depend on govt.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Govt do not target root causes because they want dependent people, they want people fighting for basic necessaries, food and shelter, because only then they can influence as they like and ensure votes. It’s all about dirty politics.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a very fresh viewpoint Aakanksha, thanks for sharing. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sure is
LikeLiked by 1 person
We all hope to see improvement.. Nice!!
LikeLike
Poverty is a multifaceted issue, requiring analyses on many institutional levels. I believe one significant problem is that so called developing countries become trapped in trading agreements where they must export crops to richer countries, while going without food themselves.l
LikeLiked by 1 person
Poverty(due to a huge and disappointed agricultural population) is a big issue even after years of independence. That is mainly because no long-term solutions are implemented by the government. Even now with huge farmer protests throughout the country and with farmer suicides, the government seems short-sighted. Farm loan waivers and a rise in the Minimum Support Price is welcome but it also won’t solve the problem. Forward contracts to handle price fluctuations and the reduction of controls in the supply chain is desperately needed. Let’s see what the Union Budget brings in this respect.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a very viable solution indeed but in a country as large as India logistical problems shall always arise and the general apathy of the government further betrays our trust in solving said problems.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Everything you say in your essay is valid. It is good to know others are thinking about these things. I see making a living wage as key to everyone doing just that — living, with a roof over their head, food in their stomach, clothes on their back, and adequate healthcare. Every government has a moral and ethical obligation to ensure this basic essentials. This is EVERY citizen, regardless of skill level. Unless you are a child or physically incapable of doing ANY work, there is an expectation that one needs to work. For families with small children — 12 and under — one of the parents should be allowed to stay home to care for them without financial backlash. Being a parent, raising up a child to be a caring, creative, productive citizen is a worthy occupation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The root causes I’d imagine are quite varied. If we accepted that they are not going away any time soon then the policy responses could include just dealing with poverty when it happens and eradicating it then by Increasing welfare payments, etc and which is probably the quickest and easiest way to help. We know that unemployment is a major cause of poverty and so something that guaranteed employment would probably be needed. I think a guarantee is needed on account of the fact that even if there are more jobs than people there is no guarantee they will get them because of discrimination or not living close enough, etc.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My blog is somewhat similar to your blog, i would be very much obliged if u could spare some time to read mine and let me know bout it
Here’s the link http://thespartanspeaks.wordpress.com/
LikeLike
okay Spartan. I’ll check it out when I get the chance. 🙂
LikeLike
Thnx buddy
LikeLike
I have read your blog about poverty. I grew up in huge family with just my Mother raising all 13 of us. Most of us have educations and great work. However, I know from my experience that governments owe their populations under those that make in excess of $250,000 a year a life. They should help them reach the poverty level of income to be able to reach further in life. When governments help the less fortunate reach educational and employment skills that they were unable to reach before. No matter what country we live in governments in one way or another get away with doing nothing to help the poor. This has to change starting with a mind set that people who can vote need to vote for the betterment of all their people not just the top 1% !! I hope this makes sense to someone out there.
LikeLike
When you mentioned the 1% you nailed it friend.
LikeLike